| ADSL non-NAT installation
ISDN dialup router, NAT Internal machines on private addresses Port mapped incoming SMTP email |
||||||
In this configuration there is a routed non-NAT internet feed (e.g. ADSL) and also a backup ISDN dialup router. The dialup router is using a conventional dialup which provides NAT from a single internet address. In this example we will assume that the ADSL router has address 123.4.5.1 and the subnet is a block of 16 (/28 or 255.255.255.240).
The FireBrick provides a conventional NAT configuration :-
Using traceroute to some address on the internet (your favourite web site for example), you will see the FireBrick, your ADSL router and a next hop. This is a good candidate for monitoring, and means if your ADSL line goes down, the you will switch to ISDN. However, if your ISP has problems (e.g. their upstream fails) and your ADSL line is actually OK, you may lose internet access and not fall back to ISDN.
Using a later address or an address on the internet would allow you to protect against failures within your ISP, and switch to ISDN. Going too far can be a problem, e.g. picking some web site. If you do this, you would find you switch to ISDN simply because the one site you were monitoring was down, even though the rest of the internet was fine.
Your ISP may be able to suggest an address to be monitored like this,
and this is the best one to use.